Gail Szeluga & JoAnna Siminerio, Fostering Community Spirit Through Real Estate (Coldwell Banker Realty - Manalapan/Marlboro) Real Estate Agent



Gail Szeluga & JoAnna Siminerio
Fostering Community Spirit Through Real Estate
location_on Manalapan, NJ — Coldwell Banker Realty - Manalapan/Marlboro
Coldwell Banker Real Estate LLC
Get to Know Gail Szeluga & JoAnna Siminerio

Real estate is a powerful thing. Your home becomes the center of your universe and a place where memories are made. The Superior Home Team of JoAnna Siminerio and Gail Szeluga is here to make your dreams a reality and patiently guide you through the process.

We are an award-winning team with 30 years of combined real estate experience. With over 400 transactions worth over $130 million, we are a force to be reckoned with. We complement each other with our drive for success and our passion for real estate. We are community driven and take pride in where we live and work.

JoAnna has been a Realtor since 2007. The level of commitment, care and concern she invests in every transaction has allowed her to exceed her goals and surpass her clients expectations.

Gail has been a Realtor since 2003. Her understanding of people and keen attention to detail, gives her clients confidence that they are in good hands.

  • ABR - Accredited Buyer Representatives
  • SRS - Seller Representative Specialists
  • SRES - Senior Residential Real Estate Specialists
  • SFR - Short Sale and Foreclosure Resource Specialists
  • e-PRO - Internet Marketing Specialists

2009 - 2017, 2019 & 2020 Circle of Excellence Sales Award

New Jersey Association of Realtors 

2007 - Present Weichert MIllion Dollar Sales and Marketing Club


Specializing in Move-up buyers, First-time homebuyers and Sellers.

Mike Elkow
We were fortunate that Gail and Joanna sold our home. They are highly responsive and patient with the numerous questions we had. Our home was on a wooded lot and not in a traditional neighborhood. Despite this it sold with a few weeks. During the process when we had challenges with permits, they went to the zoning office and got things moving. If you need agents, hire these.
Ed Clementi
JoAnna and Gail helped my wife and I both sell and buy our new house. They were there every single step of the way and went above and beyond, in my opinion, to ensure our goals were met. We have very busy schedules and it could not have been an easy task to get these deals done, but their work ethic proved tireless and success was inevitable. We always felt that we were in trustworthy hands and I can't imagine working with anyone else, should the opportunity present itself in the future.
Marie Peters
Gail and JoAnna were the best! They were professional but they also were A friend when I needed one.I recommend them very highly.. Anyone I talk To who sold their house did not have the positive experience that I had. They went above and beyond of what an agent had to do, after I sold my house I rented for a couple of years until I was ready to buy again, and They came through once again and found me the perfect house that I now Live in and love!!!
Richard Bellemare
Gail and JoAnna did a great job marketing and selling our house. They were straight forward and honest about any subject pertaining to the value of the house and what should and should not be done during the whole process. Follow up on any subject or question was fast and efficient. The result was a very fast sale at close to asking price. I would highly recommend Gail and JoAnna to anyone.
Debbie Sovern
Gail and JoAnna were wonderful to work with. They had the qualities I value in realtors: highly reachable, honest and forthcoming, professional, and supportive during the whole house-selling process. They went above and beyond with my particular situation ( selling a home and renting an apt in NYC). I feel they always had my back to protect my financial interests.
Brian Tumbarello
Choosing Gail and JoAnna is the best move you can make, if you are looking to buy a house in the Manalapan or Marlboro area. They are the best in the business and will walk you through every step in finding your new home. Although buying a home can be a difficult process, JoAnna and Gail made our buying experience as stress-free as possible. They were always available if needed and are extremely proficient at what they do. If you are looking for experienced realtors, who care for their clients, then Gail and JoAnna are the team for you.
Ligiya Silano
Moving is a very stressful time, however, JoAnna and Gail made the sale of my home as easy as possible for me. They were concerned, they were thorough, very detailed and always just a phone call away! They were extremely professional and made the entire transition from listing to closing very smooth. I highly recommend this dynamo team of real estate pros!
Howard Sisken
JoAnna and Gail are as good as it gets. They truly care about you and this is more then business as usual for them. They responded quickly to my MANY calls and worked to get us the home we wanted from day one. Would highly recommend them to anyone and everyone. Thank you!
Carl Geiger
Both Gail and JoAnna were great to work with, very professional and knowledgable about home sales in the area. For us we purchased a home out of state and unfortunately the original deal fell through after a week of moving to North Carolina. They put it back up for sale and held an open house immediately knowing our stress level was very high and we were back under contract in 2 days closing last week. Gail kept an eye on our house after we moved. We would recommend them to anyone looking to seek in the Manalapan/Marlboro area
Ted and Tammy
We sold in 6 days after signing the contract with JoAnna and Gail. We received 2 bids in addition to two additional parties very interested in the month of December! Need I say more? I never thought that we would sell so fast. They work together as a partnership... and they work very hard. I was impressed and amazed at their dedication in getting our home sold. I highly recommend them.
Ralph F
JoAnna and Gail were great to work with in terms of selling my house, particularly in a down housing market. JoAnna and Gail were very helpful, keeping me up to date on my home sale. Would use them again to buy or sell a house.
Bob and Chris
Gail and JoAnna did a great job for us in a difficult market. They were always energetic and resourceful and always willing to go the extra mile. They even took care of our dogs to enable showings that we might otherwise have had to pass on because we were not there to handle the dogs. When our daughter said she wanted to sell her house we directed her to Gail and Joanna. They delivered for her too, getting her a good price in a short period of time.
Josephine and John
My house had been on the market for some time before JoAnna sold it! JoAnna was very patient and understanding with the sale of my home. She would suggest certain things in order to sell my home, but was sensitive and understanding if I didn't want certain things done. She is also very responsible and knowledgeable about the area I lived in. She made the whole selling experience easier for me and my husband. I would highly recommend Joanna if you are selling or buying a home.
Herman and Sally
JoAnna and Gail performed excellent in marketing my house in Morganville, NJ in 2011. Their assistances were more than just the normal marketing and open house routines. They provided excellent recommendation in pricing of the house and assistances in buyer's home inspection and home appraisal processes. They even interfaced with the township in filing for the CO and helped in correcting the deficiency in the past building permits. I will hire them again if I have another house to sell in New Jersey.
Teresa and Doug
I am so thankful for JoAnna. Honestly, there aren't enough words to describe what a wonderful, professional, caring, and loyal agent JoAnna is. She listed my home and from my first meeting with her, I knew I made the right decision. She was always open and considerate. Advertising my home, open houses, and brokers opens were always done as promised. JoAnna went above and beyond with the sale of my home. Thank you JoAnna!!!
Chelsea and Kevin
JoAnna was extremely helpful in helping us find our new home in such a short amount of time. She was very professional and knowledgeable about real estate. She was always available and answered all of our questions immediately. JoAnna was never pushy and truly showed that she cared about finding us the right home for our family. She definitely went the extra mile for us. We would recommend Joanna and Gail to anyone who is looking to purchase or sell a home. It was a pleasure working with them!
Joe and Gabrielle
My husband and I were first time home buyers moving from Brooklyn, NY to Manalapan. We were nervous, scared, excited, and had a million and one questions along the way. Johanna stuck with us throughout the whole process. She answered my calls early in the morning till late at night. If she wasn't available to take my calls, she always called me back as soon as possible. JoAnna and Gail are extremely professional, friendly, and honest. They really took the time to get to know me and know what I was looking for in a house. The home buying process was very stressful and if it wasn't for JoAnna I think I would have pulled all my hair out. She educated me so much throughout the process and really fought for us when making our purchase. She helped us deal with the sellers, lawyers, and banks. She never left our side. Our relationship did not end after we closed. She continues to be a wonderful friend and resource when I have questions about events, doctors, and businesses in the area. These ladies won't just find you a house, they will find you a home. They will welcome you to the area with open arms. Thank you JoAnna and Gail for all your hard work and for caring about me and my family.
Tory and Janet
I am trying to come up with words that can describe how grateful I am that you handled the sale of my home. What you did for me was over and beyond what anyone would expect from a realtor, it was amazing. You emotionally got me through a very difficult time in my life, kept me calm, you always were focused and in control, and for all this I cannot thank you enough. When I have told friends and family about how you have been taking care of the many obstacles, they all were amazed and said I have a real "angel" working for me. "Angel" is probably the best word to describe you.
Mike and Allison
We moved to Manalapan in June 2012 after finding a wonderful home with the help of JoAnna Siminerio and Gail Szeluga!! We loved working with them throughout the whole buying process! JoAnna knew the type of home I wanted, and she did a great job in finding it for me! We were first time home buyers and they were very diligent with answering all of our questions and concerns all the way through closing. I called JoAnna at all hours of the day AND NIGHT, and she was always available to help me deal with the bank and lawyers. Home buying is a very stressful time and I don't know how I would have survived without these women! LOVE YOU GUYS!
John and Kim
JoAnna and Gail took care of it all! Including staging, pricing, marketing, negotiating, certificate of occupancy right up to the closing of our home! We heard that selling a home would be stressful, but working with these ladies made it seem easy! It didn’t stop there! Their patience in working with our family to find our next home was incredible! They were always comforting and patient even when it seemed we would never find the right home.
Ed and Judy
We can’t say enough good things about our experience in working with Gail and JoAnna to sell our home. We were forced to move as part of a government relocation program. We were nervous about the complicated process and concerned about not being able to realize the full potential of our home’s value due to challenges in the economy and the time constraints dictated by the relocation company. With their commitment, superior marketing and expert knowledge of the real estate market, JoAnna and Gail put our fears to rest and sold our home faster and for more money than we ever expected!
James and Flora
JoAnna Siminerio and Gail Szeluga we two of the greatest realtors I have ever met! From our initial meeting, they were very excited about working with me and my family during such a difficult time in our lives, selling our home due to job relocation. Both ladies were very knowledgeable of all the governmental requirements and relocation programs. Because they had previous experience, they were able to provide additional guidance to us as customers. They were very thorough, patient and persistent whether if it was for a CO inspection, appraisals or showing the home. Their professionalism, tenacity and determination always came through on everything they did for us or on our behalf. Their expertise and dedication to us as a customer allowed us to be at peace while they were selling our home while we were relocated in a new state. They are exceptional realtors and I would highly recommend them for anyone who need great dedicated realtors!!!
Billy and Filomena
As a first time home buyer, the amount of hesitations and unknowns that come along with the process are endless. I personally felt like Joanna guided me the whole way as a friend not my realtor. She made sure I met every deadline and always offered help to reach them. She would answer every single email, text and phone call immediately. She went above and beyond all my expectations. I promise any experience with Joanna and Gail will be a pleasant one. JoAnna rocks!
Lenny B
JoAnna and Gail know the real estate business extremely well. They used their expertise to help me navigate through all the hurdles associated with buying a home, which was especially difficult for me logistically since I was an out-of-state buyer. They were always responsive to my calls and never lost their patience with me until I finally found what I was looking for. And during the walk-thru on the day of closing, they were wonderful. They found some problems that were not flagged during the home inspection. I was then able to use this information as a negotiating point at closing.
Sean and Elise
JoAnna and Gail helped us sell our home and buy a bigger home for our family. These ladies are the best! They have been honest, hardworking, and a pleasure from beginning to end. They came in as a team and work that way. One of them is always available to answer a question, or solve a problem. True professionals, they assist you in showing your home and figuring out what you need in a new home. They are well informed on all the costs through the process. Their service is very personal, my kids know and love them. They helped my kids decorate their room!!! Would recommend them 100%!
Yourii and Yuliya
JoAnna and Gail are the most knowledgeable, helpful, experienced, diligent, honest and hardworking real estate professionals I have ever worked with (and I've worked with quite a few in the past) They take their time to understand your needs (be it either a buyer or a seller) and really work hard for you. Then, they make the whole process to be extra smooth and painless, from signing of the contract all the way through the closing day. If there were more real estate professionals, like them, available on the market then buying/selling real estate would have been so much easier. I highly recommend JoAnna and Gail for their excellent work!
Chris and Natalie
My fiancée and I were first time home buyers. JoAnna was very knowledgeable and helped us throughout the process answering all our questions. She guided us through the process as a friend more than just a realtor. She was great helping us as we looked at different houses. JoAnna made sure we found a house that we would love as our home! JoAnna and Gail are the team to go with and I'm glad we got to work with them.
Brian and Janine
We had just started thinking about moving when we found the house of our dreams and had not even put our home up for sale. We were impressed with the team from the start; it seemed like they had our old home up for sale and listed on all the websites overnight. I actually lost count of the number of showings we had. It did not take long for us to receive multiple offers. In addition they were able to help us negotiate and ultimately buy the house we had targeted. They are both very knowledgeable of the local market as well as the real estate process in general. They both give a lot of themselves to the process and honestly care about making their clients happy. Having said that they are also not afraid to tell you like it is which I for one really appreciated. If you are in the market or even thinking about it, don’t waste your time with other realtors. Just give Joanna and Gail a call.
Andy and Agnes
Both Gail and JoAnna are excellent Realtors. My husband and I are very glad that we got to work with them. They are always on top of things. They are very knowledgeable and helpful and are always able to provide additional assistance when necessary to help smooth the selling process. We would definitely work with them again.
Ronni and Marie
JoAnna and Gail go the extra mile and then some, they both are so personal and warm, and they will give you the facts and let you know exactly what you need to do. Ronni and I went back and forth about realtors, but in the end we listened to them, we chose them because we felt that they cared about selling our house, and going the extra mile.... and believe us...they did. They did exactly what they said they would do. YOU can trust Gail and Joanna, they won't let you down. Absolutely amazing that they sold our house for the price and the time frame given, especially given the market today. (We also had extra circumstances being that we relocated in the middle of selling this house, no matter...the girls were on it!) These ladies know their stuff and they will meet your needs and guide you in the right direction to sell your home. If you need more them and they can give you my info...happy to talk to anyone with any hesitations. I will hire them again if ever need be!!!! First and forever!!!!!

Enthusiastic, motivated & determined to succeed! Focused on selling homes in Monmouth & Middlesex Counties and the surrounding areas. We are YOUR Manalapan & Marlboro Area NJ Real Estate Specialists!