Is is a question of ethics?

By
Real Estate Agent - RE/MAX Alliance - Madison
My customer made an offer on a property. The listing agent presented it - we didn't come to agreement but we were close. My buyer said no deal so we dropped it. The listing agent calls back about two weeks later and said, if your buyer is still interested, we'll take his offer after all. So I called my buyer, he said yes so we brought the offer to the listing agent - with a three day deadline for signatures. I get a call two days later from the listing agent. "just wanted to let you know we got another offer on the property and I have to present that offer with yours." Hmmm... he told me over the phone we had a deal. I know, no signatures no deal... but a man's word isn't what it once was. He presented the offer from his buyer to his seller. No surprise, we didn't come out on top. Had I been in this situation, I would have accepted the new offer as a back-up in case our deal fell apart but a man's word should be worth something. Said he had to watch out for his client's best interests. I now have a customer who doesn't want to look at anymore properties because he cannot trust real estate agents. Note: I was very careful to explain that we were outbid and that's how we lost the deal. I did not bad-mouth or speak lowly of that agent. I did explain that since out deal wasn't signed, he had to present that offer. That's really a gray area for me though. I feel like when you tell someone you have a deal, you have a deal. What are your thoughts on this? Plesae tell me how you would've dealt with this situation if you were on either side of this. Still learning every day...
RECENT BLOG POSTS
I just wanted to say, "Thank You" to the realtor who did not show to a listing presentation the other day. She was the agent who sold my young neighbors their home and for years they have told me if they ever sold their home, she would be their agent. Of course, I graciously accepted that news an...
09/29/2009
Not having children of my own, I struggle when I have friends around with their own children. They're almost an "alien species" to me because I haven't a clue of how to relate, communicate or even act around them. I know it sounds strange but the last baby or child I was near is my nephew who's n...
04/28/2009
Don't you find comedic relief in watching the weather forecast each morning? Several of my friends were defrosting their cars this morning to head off to the office! I just waited until day break to leave! Ok more like 10 am (nanny nanny boo boo! Don't ya just love real estate?) and you know, it ...
04/08/2009
He has always thought I might be but he's now certain of it! After a recent trip to Orlando, FL (from Northern Alabama), he has decided that there's a whole other side of me he never really knew a great deal about and well, he's not sure he wanted to know if truth be told! As we were pulling out ...
04/08/2009
We have the best job on the planet! Don't you agree... ? We touch people's lives at a pivotal point... buying a home. That's a HUGE deal. It's not a $1.99 Walmart purchase we're talking about here. This is something they will remember for the rest of our lives. So why not make it the best experie...
02/04/2009
How many of us have helped a first time buyer realize their dream of home ownership? And been there to calm their nerves and ease their concerns? What a wonderful feeling when you see them step inside "their own home". But it doesn't always work out like we think. I left a client's home the other...
01/27/2009
This transaction left a bad taste in my mouth. As well as wary of next encounter with this agent... My customer made an offer on a property. The listing agent presented it - we didn't come to agreement but we were close. My buyer said no deal so we dropped it. The listing agent calls back about t...
01/26/2009
Rainer
5,035

Jennifer Minyard

Associate Broker, ABR, SFR
local_phone(256) 533-4900
smartphone(256) 603-9157
Contact The Author
Would this transaction leave a bad taste in our mouth? Not looking forward to another encounter with this agent - without doubt of coming out with that same bitter taste...